It's not "Minnesota" that is insane, it is DEMOCRATS. Most blue states have a similar law, and without any kind of exemption for sports or locker rooms or anything else. Those laws were passed with typically unanimous support from Democrats in the state legislatures, then signed into law by Democrat governors. And EVERY Democrat in Congress, both House and Senate, co-sponsors a bill to make that the law nationwide (with no exemptions).
"The Minnesota Human Rights Act has specific exemptions for single-sex athletic teams, locker rooms and bathrooms."
That's very good, because the law in most blue states does not have such an exemption. So complaining to school boards and athletic associations in those states is useless, because school boards and athletic associations have to follow the law. I wish more people understood that.
No one in MN either knows about those exemptions (average people) or will acknowledge that they exist (every lawmaker, Keith Ellison, all school board members to whom it has expressly been pointed out). I have gone through years of Twilight Zone in which I paste those exemptions in an email and send it to people and say See? And they ghost me
Keep speaking out. Suggestion: Given there’s that exemption (how does it interact with the policy of letting boys play in girls’ sports?), maybe write more about it on an op-ed, if you can find an outlet for it? More people need to know anout it.
Ha, you are using logic. If the Attorney General or Democrats or the MSHSL was using logic and science and following rules, gender ideology would never have taken root anywhere. It has only gotten this far by not following accepted procedures, by ignoring science, by using technicalities and loopholes and made-up language. To your question--how do the single-sex exemptions interact with gender self-ID--they don't. No interaction. As I mentioned in another comment, I have pasted the exemptions into an email and sent it directly to every board member of the MSHSL, and asked them to explain why they are not using these exemptions. They simply don't respond. It's very puzzling that even ADF and other law firms that defend female athletes do not use these exemptions as their argument, or if they do, they've somehow been ineffective. "It's complicated" is usually the explanation, as if only a lawyer with Title IX expertise could possibly understand what looks to the untrained eye as if they're simply pretending those exemptions don't exist. I agree--more people need to know about it.
They don't want to use the exemptions because they don't want to exclude boys from girls' sports and locker rooms because they believe boys are more important and entitled to have whatever they want. That's why they're ignoring you - and all of us.
The awkward truth is that the reason those exemptions are there is that lawmakers knew when they added gender identity to the MN Human Rights Act, it would obliterate girls and women's rights. So they wrote those exemptions to cover their ass and promptly pretended it doesn't exist
This is news to me that there is an exemption clause. Is it short enough that you could post it here? And where approximately does it occur in the Act?
Minnesota is insane with this policy. Completely lost in trans ideology.
It's not "Minnesota" that is insane, it is DEMOCRATS. Most blue states have a similar law, and without any kind of exemption for sports or locker rooms or anything else. Those laws were passed with typically unanimous support from Democrats in the state legislatures, then signed into law by Democrat governors. And EVERY Democrat in Congress, both House and Senate, co-sponsors a bill to make that the law nationwide (with no exemptions).
"The Minnesota Human Rights Act has specific exemptions for single-sex athletic teams, locker rooms and bathrooms."
That's very good, because the law in most blue states does not have such an exemption. So complaining to school boards and athletic associations in those states is useless, because school boards and athletic associations have to follow the law. I wish more people understood that.
No one in MN either knows about those exemptions (average people) or will acknowledge that they exist (every lawmaker, Keith Ellison, all school board members to whom it has expressly been pointed out). I have gone through years of Twilight Zone in which I paste those exemptions in an email and send it to people and say See? And they ghost me
Keep speaking out. Suggestion: Given there’s that exemption (how does it interact with the policy of letting boys play in girls’ sports?), maybe write more about it on an op-ed, if you can find an outlet for it? More people need to know anout it.
Ha, you are using logic. If the Attorney General or Democrats or the MSHSL was using logic and science and following rules, gender ideology would never have taken root anywhere. It has only gotten this far by not following accepted procedures, by ignoring science, by using technicalities and loopholes and made-up language. To your question--how do the single-sex exemptions interact with gender self-ID--they don't. No interaction. As I mentioned in another comment, I have pasted the exemptions into an email and sent it directly to every board member of the MSHSL, and asked them to explain why they are not using these exemptions. They simply don't respond. It's very puzzling that even ADF and other law firms that defend female athletes do not use these exemptions as their argument, or if they do, they've somehow been ineffective. "It's complicated" is usually the explanation, as if only a lawyer with Title IX expertise could possibly understand what looks to the untrained eye as if they're simply pretending those exemptions don't exist. I agree--more people need to know about it.
They don't want to use the exemptions because they don't want to exclude boys from girls' sports and locker rooms because they believe boys are more important and entitled to have whatever they want. That's why they're ignoring you - and all of us.
The awkward truth is that the reason those exemptions are there is that lawmakers knew when they added gender identity to the MN Human Rights Act, it would obliterate girls and women's rights. So they wrote those exemptions to cover their ass and promptly pretended it doesn't exist
Sarah, THANK YOU for all you do. So many of us deeply appreciate your efforts!
This is news to me that there is an exemption clause. Is it short enough that you could post it here? And where approximately does it occur in the Act?
I hope the protect girls movement can come to Oregon, following in the footsteps of WA, CO, NE and AZ.